Is GatorGuard as Good as Silt Fencing?

When it comes to effective sediment control, it’s essential to invest in reliable solutions that not only offer superior performance but also provide long-lasting and eco-friendly alternatives. One such solution is the GatorGuard, a reusable sediment control wattle that surpasses the limitations of traditional straw wattles or silt fences. With the GatorGuard, you can bid farewell to the constant need for replacements as it boasts an impressive 20 times less dirt loss compared to straw wattles. Additionally, it’s UV resistance ensures durability, making it a cost-effective choice in the long run. Conveniently shipped in three 25-foot rolls, the GatorGuard offers a total length of 75 feet, providing ample coverage for your sediment control needs.

What Are the Benefits of Silt Fences?

Silt fences offer a range of benefits when it comes to erosion and sediment control on construction sites. One of the main advantages of silt fences is their ability to effectively filter out suspended solids from stormwater runoff. This is crucial in preventing sediment-laden water from leaving the site and polluting nearby bodies of water.

This makes it a popular choice for projects with tight budgets.

They can be used on various terrains and are effective in controlling sediment runoff in a range of applications, such as construction sites, agricultural fields, and road construction projects.

By effectively trapping sediment particles, they help to maintain water quality and protect aquatic ecosystems. This is particularly important in areas where stormwater runoff can have harmful effects on sensitive habitats and aquatic life.

Silt fencing plays a crucial role in preventing erosion by acting as a temporary sediment barrier. This porous fabric barrier effectively captures sediment-laden stormwater, allowing the settling processes to retain the sediment. By utilizing wooden or metal posts, silt fencing isn’t only cost-effective but also easy to remove when no longer needed. Let’s delve into the specific mechanisms and benefits of silt fencing in preventing erosion.

How Does Silt Fencing Prevent Erosion?

Silt fencing is a widely used method for preventing erosion and controlling sediment runoff. This is particularly important on construction sites, where soil disturbance is common and can lead to significant erosion if left uncontrolled.

The construction of a silt fence typically involves driving wooden or metal posts into the ground and attaching a porous fabric to create a barrier. The fabric is designed to allow the passage of water but retains sediment particles, preventing them from being transported away. As stormwater flows through the fabric, it slows down, allowing for settling processes to take place and sediment to be trapped.

It can be used in various construction or land development projects, including residential, commercial, and industrial sites. It’s particularly effective in areas with larger amounts of sediment-laden stormwater runoff, such as sites with extensive earthmoving or grading activities.

In recent years, alternative erosion control products, such as GatorGuard, have emerged as potential alternatives to traditional silt fencing. GatorGuard is a geotextile product that functions similarly to silt fencing but offers additional benefits, such as higher flow capacity and longer lifespan.

The Benefits and Drawbacks of Using Traditional Silt Fencing

Traditional silt fencing is a commonly used method for sediment control in construction sites and other areas where soil erosion is a concern. One of the main benefits of silt fencing is it’s ability to effectively trap sediment and prevent it from entering nearby water bodies. This helps to protect the water quality and prevent pollution.

However, there are some drawbacks to using traditional silt fencing. One of the main issues is that it can be easily damaged or overwhelmed by heavy rain or high water flow. If the fencing isn’t properly installed or maintained, it may fail to contain sediment and allow it to escape into waterways.

Another drawback is that traditional silt fencing requires regular monitoring and maintenance to remain effective. This includes inspecting and repairing any damages, clearing out trapped sediment, and ensuring the fencing is properly in place. Failure to do so can result in reduced effectiveness and increased sediment runoff.

Overall, while traditional silt fencing can be a useful tool for sediment control, it’s it’s limitations. It’s effectiveness can be affected by various factors, and regular maintenance is necessary to ensure optimal performance. Alternatives such as GatorGuard may offer additional benefits and better performance in certain situations.

Taking care of your silt fence is crucial to ensure it’s effectiveness in sediment control. Regular inspection, repairs, and sediment removal are key maintenance tasks that help to prolong the lifespan of your fence. At Ecospill, we offer top-quality silt fence materials that are designed to last longer and make maintenance a breeze.

What Is the Maintenance of Silt Fence?

When it comes to maintaining your silt fence, regular inspection is key. It’s important to constantly monitor the condition of your fence to ensure it’s effectiveness. Inspect the fabric for any signs of damage such as tears or holes, as these can compromise it’s ability to trap sediment. Additionally, check the stakes for stability and make sure they’re securely fastened into the ground.

If you notice any damages to your silt fence, it’s essential to repair them promptly. Patching up any tears or holes in the fabric will prevent sediment from escaping and maintain the integrity of the barrier. This can be done using repair kits available in the market or by replacing damaged sections entirely.

Another aspect of silt fence maintenance is the removal of built-up sediment. Over time, sediment can accumulate at the base of the fence, reducing it’s effectiveness. This can be done by manual labor or by using specialized equipment such as vacuum trucks or excavators.

To make silt fence maintenance easier and more efficient, it’s advisable to invest in high-quality silt fence materials. Ecospill offers durable silt fence materials that are designed to withstand the elements and last longer. These materials are made from high-quality fabrics that provide superior filtration and erosion control.

Tips for Preventing Silt Fence Damage During Construction Activities

  • Follow proper installation guidelines for the silt fence
  • Regularly inspect the fence for any signs of damage or weakness
  • Maintain a clear buffer zone around the fence to prevent accidental damage
  • Avoid excessive vehicle or equipment traffic near the fence
  • Properly dispose of any debris or sediment that accumulates near the fence
  • Consider using additional erosion control measures in high-risk areas
  • Train construction personnel on the importance of silt fence protection
  • Monitor weather conditions and reinforce the fence during heavy rainfall or storms
  • Repair any damage to the fence immediately to prevent further erosion issues
  • Regularly communicate with the construction team to ensure everyone is aware of the importance of protecting the silt fence

Source: Best Practices for Silt Fence Maintenance – Ecospill


In conclusion, based on the comparison between GatorGuard and silt fencing, it’s clear that GatorGuard is a superior option for sediment control. It’s advantages, such as being 20 times less prone to dirt loss compared to straw wattles, UV resistance, and durability, make it a worthwhile investment. With a total length of 75' and shipping in three convenient 25' rolls, GatorGuard offers a practical and efficient solution for sediment control.

Scroll to Top