Should My Picket Fence Be White or Cedar?

When it comes to choosing wood for your picket fence, you might find yourself deliberating between two popular options: white or cedar. White Cedar, also known as Thuja occidentalis, is an evergreen coniferous tree native to eastern Canada and parts of the northeastern United States. This wood isn’t only aesthetically pleasing but also offers a range of practical advantages. The natural oils present in White Cedar make it resistant to mold, warping, insects, and damage from UV rays. In addition to it’s durability, White Cedar adds a touch of elegance to any landscape with it’s light, creamy color.

Are White Fences a Good Idea?

White fences may look elegant and classic, but they can be a nightmare to maintain. They tend to show dirt and stains easily, requiring frequent cleaning and upkeep. Even with regular cleaning, white fences can become discolored over time due to exposure to the elements. This can result in a less than appealing appearance, which may not be desirable for homeowners who want their fences to always look pristine.

On the other hand, cedar fences offer several advantages over white ones. Cedar is a naturally durable and long-lasting wood, making it a great choice for outdoor structures like fences. It’s inherent resistance to rot and insect damage, reducing the need for frequent repairs or treatments. Additionally, cedar has a beautiful natural color that can enhance the overall aesthetic of your garden.

The woods natural oils act as a protective barrier against the effects of moisture and UV rays, meaning you don’t have to worry as much about staining or sealing the fence. Over time, cedar fences will naturally age to a silver-gray color, which can add a rustic and charming look to your property.

Consider these factors and choose the option that best suits your style and practicality requirements.

The Impact of Climate and Weather on the Durability of Different Fence Materials

  • Wood fences:
    – Exposure to constant moisture can cause warping, rotting, and mold growth.
    – Extreme heat and sun exposure may lead to drying, cracking, and discoloration.
    – Freezing temperatures can cause the expansion and contraction of wood, leading to structural damage.
  • Vinyl fences:
    – Generally more resistant to moisture, but excessive heat may cause fading and warping.
    – Extreme cold temperatures can make vinyl brittle, increasing the risk of cracks or breakage.
    – Prolonged exposure to UV rays can cause fading and degradation of the material.
  • Metal fences:
    – Rust formation is a primary concern when exposed to constant moisture.
    – Extreme temperature fluctuations can cause metal to expand and contract, potentially leading to structural issues.
    – Direct sunlight can cause fading of paint or coatings on the metal surface.
  • Composite fences:
    – Generally more durable than wood, with resistance against rot, pests, and weathering.
    – However, composite materials may still be vulnerable to fading and discoloration over time.
    – Extreme temperature changes can cause expansion or contraction, affecting the fence’s overall stability.
  • Chain-link fences:
    – Galvanized steel coatings offer good resistance against weather elements.
    – However, over time, exposure to moisture can lead to rust formation and degradation of the fence.
    – Chain-link fences are generally less affected by temperature changes compared to other materials.

Cedar wood stands out with it’s characteristic reddish color, distinct grain pattern, and charming white accents, which add warmth and beauty to any fence. It’s natural appeal surpasses that of pine, catching the eye with it’s unique aesthetics.

Does Cedar Look Better Than Pine?

When it comes to choosing the perfect material for your picket fence, the decision between cedar and pine is an important one. While both options have their own merits, many homeowners find that cedar has a distinct advantage in terms of aesthetics. Cedar wood is easily recognizable with it’s distinct reddish hue and unique grain pattern on the surface. These natural characteristics give cedar a visually appealing quality that’s hard to replicate with other woods.

Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on your personal preference and the specific needs of your outdoor space. Consult with a professional to help you make an informed decision and choose the best option for your home.

The Durability and Lifespan of Cedar vs Pine

When deciding between a white picket fence or one made from cedar, it’s important to consider the durability and lifespan of each material. Cedar is known for it’s natural resistance to rot, decay, and insect damage due to it’s tannins and natural oils. This makes cedar fences highly durable and able to withstand outdoor elements for many years.

Pine, on the other hand, is a softer wood and less resistant to rot and insect damage. Although it can be treated to improve it’s durability, it still requires regular maintenance to prevent decay over time.

In terms of lifespan, cedar fences tend to have a longer lifespan than pine fences. With proper care and maintenance, a well-built cedar fence can last for several decades. Pine fences, on the other hand, may require more frequent repairs or replacements due to rot or insect damage.

Ultimately, the decision between a white picket fence or cedar fence depends on your aesthetic preferences and budget. While a white fence may offer a traditional and timeless look, a cedar fence provides durability and longevity that may be worth the investment.

Source: Which Wood Is Best for A Fence, Pine or Cedar?

On the other hand, if you’re not fond of DIY projects or have a limited budget, you might want to consider other fencing options that can provide similar security and aesthetic appeal.

Should I Get a White Picket Fence?

When it comes to deciding on the color for your picket fence, one of the options that often comes up is white. A white picket fence has long been associated with the classic American dream, evoking images of neatly manicured lawns and idyllic suburban living. But is a white picket fence the right choice for your home?

The clean, crisp lines of a white fence can create a beautiful contrast against vibrant greenery or colorful flowers. It can serve as a frame for your landscaping, enhancing the overall aesthetic appeal of your front yard.

However, it’s important to consider the maintenance that comes with a white picket fence. While the pristine white color may be visually appealing, it can quickly become dirty or discolored due to exposure to the elements. Regular cleaning and upkeep are necessary to keep your white picket fence looking it’s best.

Alternatively, you might consider a cedar picket fence. Cedar is a popular choice for it’s natural beauty and durability. It’s a distinctive reddish-brown color that can add warmth and character to your front yard.

While white vinyl fences are known for their durable and low-maintenance nature, they aren’t completely impervious to dirt and mildew. Over time, these fences can accumulate dirt and may develop discoloration due to the growth of mold. However, there are ways to address these issues and keep your white vinyl fence looking pristine.

Do White Vinyl Fences Get Dirty?

When considering whether to choose a white vinyl or cedar picket fence, it’s important to weigh the maintenance requirements of each material. While white vinyl fences offer a clean and polished look initially, they aren’t immune to dirt and mildew build-up. Over time, these fences can become discolored due to mold growth and the accumulation of dirt particles.

In reality, these fences will eventually show signs of dirt and mildew, especially in areas with high humidity or damp climates. As organic matter settles on the surface of the fence, it can create an ideal environment for mold growth, resulting in unsightly discoloration.

To preserve the pristine appearance of a white vinyl fence, regular cleaning is necessary. This can be done using mild soapy water and a soft brush or sponge. Additionally, periodic inspections should be performed to ensure that no mold or mildew is present. If any discoloration or growth is detected, a more intensive cleaning regimen may be required.

On the other hand, a cedar wood fence also requires maintenance to prevent dirt and mildew build-up. The natural color variation and grain patterns of cedar can help mask any dirt or mildew that may accumulate over time. As a result, cedar fences may require less regular cleaning to maintain their appearance.

Ultimately, the choice between white vinyl and cedar should be based on personal preferences, desired maintenance level, and the overall aesthetic you’re trying to achieve for your property.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Choosing a White Vinyl Fence Over a Cedar Picket Fence

  • Low maintenance
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Resistant to weather and pests
  • No need for staining or painting
  • Easier to clean
  • Wide range of styles and colors to choose from
  • Provides privacy
  • Doesn’t rot or warp
  • Cost-effective in the long run
  • Higher upfront cost
  • May not have the same natural look as cedar
  • Less environmentally friendly
  • Not as customizable as cedar
  • Less resistant to impact or damage

Additionally, cedar’s natural oils give it a pleasant aroma and help to repel insects. On the other hand, pine is more commonly used for indoor projects like furniture or cabinetry due to it’s affordability and versatility. However, it can still be used outdoors with proper treatment and maintenance. Overall, the choice between cedar and pine ultimately depends on the specific project and individual preferences.

Is Cedar or Pine Better for Outdoor?

Choosing the right type of wood for outdoor projects such as fences or decking can be a key decision in ensuring the longevity and durability of your structure. When deciding between cedar and pine, it’s important to consider their unique characteristics and how they’ll fare in different weather conditions.

Cedar, renowned for it’s natural resistance to moisture and insects, is an excellent choice for outdoor projects. It’s natural oils act as a barrier against decay-causing agents, making it a preferred option in regions with high humidity or frequent exposure to rain. Additionally, cedars dimensional stability ensures that it remains straight and sturdy, with minimal warping or splitting over time. These qualities, combined with proper sealing or staining, enhance it’s ability to withstand the harsh effects of wet weather and prolonged exposure to the elements.

On the other hand, pine, a more common and easily available choice, also has it’s uses in outdoor projects. It’s typically less expensive than cedar, making it a popular option for homeowners on a budget. However, when used outdoors, pine requires proper treatment and maintenance to protect it from moisture damage and insect infestations. Pine is more susceptible to rot and decay, especially in damp or humid environments.

Both cedar and pine have a range of uses, and the choice ultimately depends on your specific project and preferences.


It’s light color adds a touch of elegance and sophistication to your outdoor space. It’s a renewable resource that requires minimal maintenance, making it a cost-effective option in the long run.

Scroll to Top